Brand New Heartache:The Everly Brothers. Top of the charts in 1958. #1. A new boy came to town, I ain't seen you around. I feel a brand new heartache comin' on. #2. It happened once before, when a guy moved in next door. I feel a brand new heartache comin' on. CHORUS: Why can't I trust in you? Why do you try to make me blue, the way you do? #3. Last night we planned a ball, you never showed at all. I feel a brand new heartache comin' on. CHORUS: Why can't I trust in you? Why do you try to make me blue, the way you do? #3. Right now we've got a date, and you're three hours late. I feel a brand new heartache comin' on. A fifties smash from Kraziekhat.