Evelyn Is Not Real My Morning Jacket The Tennessee Fire Evelyn I hope this cant be true. Evelyn, you know my hearts with you. Don't try to tell me there's another boy, Don't try to use me like a lover’s toy. Evelyn you know this cant be true. From what I found the ground remains with you. Don't try to tell me there's another boy, Don't try and use me like a lover’s toy. Aw take it away Johnny… Don't try to tell me there's another boy, Don't try and use me like a lover’s toy. Evelyn I hope this cant be true. Evelyn, you broke my heart and left me here so blue. Any suggestions please let me know.