Cara Mia Mine – Gene Pitney (covered by Jay & the Americans in 1965) CaraMia why must we say goodbye? Each time we part my heart wants to die Darling hear my prayer Cara Mia fair I'll be yr love til the end of time Cara Mia mine, Cara Mia mine, Cara Mia mine. CaraMia why must we say goodbye? Each time we part my heart wants to die Darling hear my prayer Cara Mia fair I'll be yr love til the end of time Cara Mia mine, Cara Mia mine, Cara Mia mine.